| |
Is It All In Your Head?
| by Jack A. Medina, M.A. and Roy E. Vartabedian, Dr.P.H. |
March 10, 2008 |
|
|
| |
Athletes and coaches have high expectations.
One is that if you lift weights, you will get
bigger, faster, and stronger. Another is, if
you spend money on a supplement you will get
even bigger, faster and stronger than you
would from just training.
|
|
| |
|
Opinion or Science?
If you make decisions based on solid
scientific evidence, not weak, opinion-based
claims, you already know that the majority of
supplements do not meet the manufacturers'
claims and will not make you grow bigger,
faster, and stronger. Why do coaches
recommend them and athletes take them? Was
the science wrong? NO!
|
|
|
| |
|
What the Research Says
Research from Chicago State University says
"The gains are all in your head." Here's a
fact: whatever you put in your body will have
an effect. This holds true for food, liquids,
drugs, and nutritional supplements. The
question is, are the results real or
imagined? You might take a nutritional
supplement for the advertising promises
being made, and due to this "promise" you
expect certain results, even when good
research has proven there are no
physiological gains associated with this
supplement. The effect is psychological and
is termed the "placebo effect," often defined
as creating an expectation or belief for a
given effect; an expectation that produces
that effect.
Ironically, the placebo effect is not
entirely in your head. Psychological research
has demonstrated that what you expect to
happen, can happen even though the
"supplement" or "drug" was nothing more than
a placebo. If this is true, are sports
supplements really worth the expense? NO!
And beyond that, what is the placebo effect
when it comes to strength gain?
|
|
|
| |
|
Placebos and Strength Training
The study I refer to: "The Effect of
Placebo-Induced Changes in Expectancies on
Maximal Force Production in College
Students," Journal of Applied Sport
Psychology 19:116-124, 2007, set out to
investigate whether a bogus supplement
consisting of milk-sugar would increase strength.
The results said "yes," it did just that. Not
only did the placebo group increase strength,
but once these subjects were told the
supplement did not work, their performance
decreased to almost the same level as the
control group which did not receive a
supplement.
What does this mean? It means even the
suggestion that whatever you ingest may
increase your strength can significantly
increase your strength. This is why so many
athletes take supplements even though the
research on that supplement clearly shows it
provides no ergogenic (physical
performance-enhancing) benefits. The
increases are not
due to the supplements' ingredients.
It's important to note this study was set up
in a manner in which strength gains in
response to actual training did not occur; in
other words, whatever strength gains the
subjects experienced were solely do to
psychological reasons.
What science has been able to determine is
that positive expectations can increase
dopamine release in the brain and in turn
affect changes in motor function and
performance.
|
|
|
| |
|
The Bottom Line
When the research on most nutritional
supplements shows they have no ergogenic
benefits, yet athletes and coaches believe
they do, the effect is psychological and not
due to the supplements' ingredients.
Conclusion: It's not worth your time and
money investing in any supplement, dietary or
otherwise, with nothing but hype and
testimonials to substantiate claims being
made. Use only products which have
peer-reviewed published research on performance
enhancement or health benefits.
What you believe, you can achieve. But it's
much better to take a supplement that really
benefits your body, then you will receive both
the "real" benefits and your "belief"
benefits as well!
|
|
|
| |
For more information on these and other
topics of interest in fitness and nutrition,
check out our books and services available on
our websites:
The
Winning Edge: Fueling & Training the Body for
Peak Performance (new 2nd Edition)
PowerPack
for the Winning Edge
More
Fuel for the Winning Edge
Nutripoints:
Health Eating Made Simple!
Nutripoints
& Optimal Nutrition
Nutripoints
QuickCheck Evaluation
List
of All Products
See you next month!
Yours for fitness and health,
Jack A. Medina, M.A.Roy E. Vartabedian, Dr.P.H.
Designs for Fitness & Welless
phone:
541-474-2454 or Toll-Free Order Line: 1-866-204-8786
|
|
|